Holiday 2025

Let us spoil you this season by taking the hassle out of dessert prep. Like everything we craft, our desserts are made without dairy, eggs, honey, peanuts or tree nuts. Note that our GF options are baked in the same oven we use for our regular pies and for this reason are not recommended for those highly sensitive to gluten or wheat. Orders are available for pick-up on Saturday 12/20 and Christmas Eve Wednesday 12/24.

Orders will close Tuesday 12/16 (or once slots are filled) for 12/20 pickups, and Tuesday 12/16 (or once slots are filled) for 12/20 pickups, or Saturday 12/20 (or once slots are filled) for 12/24 pickups. We will post availability updates here and on Facebook and Instagram.

When ordering, please double check your pickup date. Due to the precise production schedule for holiday desserts, we cannot make you new desserts, hold desserts for another day, or refund your order if you select the wrong pickup day. Your order must be picked up on the day you select.

Please note the following before placing an order:

  • Available for online pre-order only.

  • If you’re looking to order donuts, drinks, or Great Big Donuts, please go through our normal online ordering page. This page is for dessert orders specifically.

  • All preorder pickups are available in Kittery only. (Preorders of any kind are not available in Portsmouth.)

  • Please note that we cannot accept gift cards for desserts. Sorry for the inconvenience.

  • Your order must be picked up on the day you select. Unclaimed desserts will be donated after closing time and will not be refunded.

  • Cancellation Policy: Orders cannot be changed once submitted. Cancellations for a refund will be accepted through Friday 12/19 at noon. Cancellations for any reason, including weather, after that date cannot be refunded.

Chocolate Cream Pie // 26

New this season, we’ve taken chocolate cream pie to the next level with dark chocolate mousse, chocolate donut-based crust, and rich whipped cream.
9” pie. 8 servings.
This pie is naturally gluten-free.

Dutch Apple Pie // 24

This flavorful fall Streusel-topped Dutch Apple Pie is packed with apples and spice and everything nice. Our pies are lovingly made from scratch just for you. 9” pie. 8 servings.
Gluten-free $30.

Lemon Tart // 26

A gorgeous and fresh lemon curd tart topped with buttercream and berries. 9” pie. 8 servings.
Sorry, gluten-free not available.

Sugar Plum Pie // 24

A pie for the child in all of us. A unique sweet-tart filling of plums, blackberries, and cranberries is topped with a pretty snowflake design and sugared cranberries. 9” pie. 8 servings.
Sorry, gluten-free not available.

Great Big Donut // 30

Great Big Donuts are always available through our normal online ordering page. Please visit that page for donut, drink, and GBD orders.
Gluten-free $38.

Brioche Rolls // 8

Our own scratch-made dinner rolls loaded with soft, buttery goodness. 8 rolls.
Sorry, gluten-free not available.

Please continue below to place a holiday order. For donut, drink, and GBD orders, please visit our regular online ordering page.

GO TO ORDER PAGE

Holiday Week Shop Hours

Normal hours for any dates not listed below.

Kittery Special Hours

Wednesday 12/24 7am–1pm
Thursday 12/25 Closed
Wednesday 12/31 7am–1pm
Thursday 1/1 Closed

Portsmouth Special Hours

Wednesday 12/24 8am–2pm
Thursday 12/25 Closed
Wednesday 12/31 8am–2pm
Thursday 1/1 Closed